Skip to content
Invitation-only alpha. Features and limits may change as we learn from testing.

DMARC needs review

✕Blocks setup · Reason code: dmarc_compatibility_requires_review · Next action: You

Receivers find a domain’s DMARC policy in one of two ways: the current DNS tree walk and the older public suffix list. weneed.email checks both. When they disagree, or a policy can’t be found or resolved, setup waits for review. The project lists the reasons, for example:

Reason Meaning
no_policy No DMARC record was found.
policy_evidence_unresolved The DMARC lookup didn’t complete.
policy_presence One method finds a policy, the other doesn’t.
effective_policy The two methods arrive at a different policy.
policy_domain, organizational_domain The two methods use a different domain’s record.
alignment_mode adkim or aspf differ.
legacy_partial_enforcement Older receivers apply your policy to less than 100% of mail (pct).

Open the domain step in Control. The Existing DMARC policy row says what to change and, where a record is needed, shows its name and value with copy buttons. Save the change at your DNS provider, then select Check DNS records.

Situation What Control asks you to do
No DMARC record Add v=DMARC1; p=none; adkim=s; aspf=r at _dmarc.yourdomain.com. It only asks for reports and rejects nothing.
pct below 100 on your domain’s own record Remove the pct tag and keep the other tags. If you’re not ready to enforce on all mail, use p=none.
You send from a subdomain and its policy is inherited from the parent domain Add a policy directly at _dmarc. plus your sending domain. Control fills in a value that keeps the policy and report addresses receivers apply today, and changes nothing for your other domains.
More than one DMARC record at one name Keep exactly one record starting with v=DMARC1 and delete the others.
A record that can’t be read Correct it: it starts with v=DMARC1, has p=none, p=quarantine or p=reject, and lists each tag once.
The lookup didn’t finish Nothing to change. The next check retries automatically.

Only if Control can’t name a single record that fixes it does it ask you to write to help@weneed.email.